Chapter Two

U.S. Constitution

September 17, 1787

The Declaration of Independence told the world what America believed. The Constitution would determine whether those beliefs could survive. In the summer of 1787, fifty-five delegates gathered in Philadelphia under a vow of secrecy and did something that had never been successfully done before: they designed a government from scratch. The result — a document of just 4,543 words — remains the oldest written national constitution still in use. It was, as Benjamin Franklin called it, a miracle.

Key People

The architects, champions, and critics who shaped the Constitution and fought for its ratification.

James Madison
1751–1836

The "Father of the Constitution." At 36, the youngest major architect of the Convention, Madison arrived in Philadelphia with a blueprint that became the Virginia Plan. His detailed notes provide our only complete record of the debates. Later co-authored The Federalist Papers and became the fourth President. Small in stature but towering in intellect.

If men were angels, no government would be necessary.
George Washington
1732–1799

President of the Constitutional Convention. His presence gave the proceedings legitimacy — delegates knew he would be the first President, so they trusted the powers they were creating. Said almost nothing during debates but his silent authority kept the fractious convention together. His willingness to serve only two terms set a precedent that lasted until FDR.

Let us raise a standard to which the wise and honest can repair; the rest is in the hands of God.
Benjamin Franklin
1706–1790

At 81, the oldest delegate. Contributed wisdom, humor, and compromise when tensions ran high. His final speech urging unanimous support despite individual reservations helped secure ratification. Famously said the rising sun carved on Washington's chair was indeed rising, not setting — expressing hope for the new nation.

I consent, Sir, to this Constitution because I expect no better, and because I am not sure, that it is not the best.
Alexander Hamilton
1755–1804

New York delegate who attended sporadically but became the Constitution's greatest champion. Wrote 51 of the 85 Federalist Papers explaining and defending the document. His vision of a strong central government with commercial power shaped early America. First Secretary of the Treasury. Died in a duel with Aaron Burr in 1804.

Why has government been instituted at all? Because the passions of men will not conform to the dictates of reason and justice, without constraint.
Gouverneur Morris
1752–1816

Pennsylvania delegate who actually wrote the final text of the Constitution. The eloquent preamble — "We the People of the United States, in order to form a more perfect Union..." — is his work. Also designed the decimal-based U.S. currency system. Lost his leg in a carriage accident but never lost his sharp wit.

We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Roger Sherman
1721–1793

Connecticut delegate who proposed the "Great Compromise" that saved the Convention. Balanced large and small states' interests by creating a bicameral legislature: the House based on population, the Senate with equal representation. The only founder to sign all four founding documents.

The question is not what rights naturally belong to man, but how they may be most equally and effectually guarded in society.
George Mason
1725–1792

Virginia delegate who drafted the Virginia Declaration of Rights, which influenced the Bill of Rights. Refused to sign the Constitution because it lacked individual rights protections and allowed slavery to continue. His objections led directly to the Bill of Rights being added. Principled dissent can improve the final product.

There is no Declaration of Rights... The Declaration of Rights in the separate States are no security.
Patrick Henry
1736–1799

Virginia's fiery orator who refused to attend the Convention ("I smelt a rat") and fought ratification. His opposition forced Federalists to promise a Bill of Rights. Sometimes the opposition strengthens the final result.

I smelt a rat in Philadelphia, tending toward the monarchy.
John Jay
1745–1829

New York lawyer who wasn't at the Convention but co-wrote The Federalist Papers (5 essays) and became the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. Shows that supporters beyond the Convention were crucial to ratification.

Key Dates

From the failures of the Articles of Confederation to the birth of a new framework for self-governance.

1781
Articles of Confederation Take Effect
America's first constitution creates a weak central government with no power to tax or regulate commerce. States act like independent countries. The system doesn't work.
August 1786
Shays' Rebellion
Debt-ridden farmers in Massachusetts rebel against foreclosures. The federal government has no army to respond. Wealthy elites panic. This crisis convinces many that a stronger government is needed.
February 21, 1787
Congress Endorses Constitutional Convention
Congress authorizes a convention "for the sole and express purpose of revising the Articles of Confederation." The delegates will exceed this mandate by writing an entirely new constitution.
May 25, 1787
Convention Officially Begins
With delegates from seven states present, they elect Washington as president of the Convention. They immediately adopt a rule of strict secrecy — no leaks to the press. This allows honest debate.
May 29, 1787
Virginia Plan Presented
Madison's proposal for a strong national government with three branches and proportional representation. Large states love it; small states hate it. Battle lines are drawn.
June 15, 1787
New Jersey Plan Presented
William Paterson's counterproposal keeping equal state representation. Small states' response to the Virginia Plan. The Convention now faces a fundamental choice.
July 16, 1787
The Great Compromise
Roger Sherman's solution passes by one vote: the House based on population, the Senate with equal state representation. Saves the Convention from collapse. Without this, there is no Constitution.
August 29, 1787
Slavery Compromises
The Three-Fifths Compromise counts enslaved people as 3/5 of a person for representation and taxation. The slave trade is allowed to continue until 1808. The Constitution's original sin is codified.
September 17, 1787
Constitution Signed
39 of 42 remaining delegates sign. Three refuse: Mason, Randolph, and Gerry. Franklin urges unanimous support. The document goes to Congress and then the states for ratification.
October 27, 1787
Federalist Papers Begin Publication
Hamilton, Madison, and Jay start publishing essays in New York newspapers explaining and defending the Constitution. 85 essays appear over seven months. Essential to the ratification campaign.
June 21, 1788
New Hampshire Becomes Ninth State
Ratification is achieved! But major states Virginia and New York haven't approved yet. Without them, the Constitution might fail in practice.
June 25, 1788
Virginia Ratifies
After intense debate, Virginia approves 89-79. Madison and Washington's home state is aboard. Patrick Henry leads the opposition but loses.
July 26, 1788
New York Ratifies
Hamilton's tireless advocacy wins a narrow 30-27 vote. All major states are now in. The new government can begin.
April 30, 1789
Washington Inaugurated
The first President takes the oath of office on the balcony of Federal Hall in New York. The Constitution moves from paper to practice.
December 15, 1791
Bill of Rights Ratified
The first ten amendments become part of the Constitution, addressing the concerns of Mason, Gerry, and the Anti-Federalists. The Constitution is now complete.

Suggested Reading

From accessible narratives to essential primary sources — books for every level of interest.

📘 For General Readers

Plain, Honest Men: The Making of the American Constitution by Richard Beeman (2009)
The most readable single-volume account of the Constitutional Convention. Brings the debates and personalities to life. Perfect starting point for understanding the summer of 1787.
The Summer of 1787: The Men Who Invented the Constitution by David O. Stewart (2007)
Narrative history focusing on the key players and their compromises. Shows the Constitution as a product of negotiation, not divine inspiration.
Miracle at Philadelphia by Catherine Drinker Bowen (1966)
Classic narrative history that remains highly readable. Makes the delegates human and the debates dramatic. A great introduction to why it was called a "miracle."

📖 For Deeper Study

Ratification: The People Debate the Constitution, 1787–1788 by Pauline Maier (2010)
Comprehensive account of the state-by-state ratification battles. Shows that approval was never certain — the Constitution almost failed.
The Quartet: Orchestrating the Second American Revolution by Joseph J. Ellis (2015)
Focuses on Washington, Hamilton, Madison, and Jay as the four key figures who made the Constitution happen. Argues they staged a peaceful revolution.
Original Meanings by Jack Rakove (1996)
Pulitzer Prize winner examining what the framers actually intended. Essential for understanding originalist interpretation debates.

📜 Primary Sources

The Federalist Papers by Hamilton, Madison, and Jay (1787–88)
Essential reading. Start with Federalist No. 10 (Madison on factions), No. 51 (checks and balances), and No. 78 (Hamilton on the judiciary).
The Anti-Federalist Papers edited by Ralph Ketcham (2003)
The other side of the ratification debate. Patrick Henry, George Mason, and others argue against the Constitution. Understanding their concerns is crucial — they led to the Bill of Rights.
Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787 by James Madison
Madison's daily notes provide our only complete record of Convention debates. See what was actually said — and what was kept secret for 50 years.

📚 For Students & Teachers

A Brilliant Solution: Inventing the American Constitution by Carol Berkin (2002)
Accessible overview written for general audiences and students. Clear, concise, and compelling.
Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow (2004)
The biography that inspired the musical. Essential for understanding the Federalist vision and the ratification campaign.

Discussion Questions

Questions designed to spark genuine debate about the Constitution's origins, compromises, and enduring relevance.

Primary Sources

Original documents from the founding era, freely available in the public domain.

📜 The Documents

Complete text of the Constitution including all amendments, hosted by the Avalon Project at Yale Law School.
Hamilton, Madison, and Jay's complete essays defending and explaining the Constitution. Start with Nos. 10, 51, and 78.
America's first constitution — the document the framers replaced. Reading it reveals exactly why the Convention was necessary.
Madison's detailed daily record of the Convention debates — our only complete account of what was said behind closed doors. Library of Congress digital collection (Farrand's Records).

🏛️ Authoritative Online Resources

An annotated, clause-by-clause guide to the Constitution with commentary from leading legal scholars across the political spectrum. Excellent for students and teachers.
Searchable collection of letters and papers from the founders, including correspondence during the Convention and ratification debates.

Continue Exploring